Regenerative Turbine Aeration Technology
by Stuart Ward
October 3, 2011
In order to acquire precise control of input and output fluid/gas parameters, wastewater managers and technicians can utilize a regenerative turbine pump, which fully optimizes the gas dissolution process that properly treats wastewater, time after time. Once such parameters have been completely controlled, a well-designed wastewater treatment system should be able to initiate all necessary operating duties after each start-up. To enlighten wastewater professionals as they discover and use such gas-dissolving technology, this feature will focus on the various potential benefits that regenerative turbine technology may offer.
Gas dissolution and regenerative turbines During the first step of the regenerative turbine process, gas is dissolved into a fluid solution through the application of a pre-determined amount of pressure. The regenerative turbine pump applies such pressure, through a combined triple-action force (centrifugal, axial and friction), to the gas and fluid during a single pass through the pump head. Whether dissolving compressed or atmospheric air, nitrogen or other gasses to the fluid, the regenerative turbine pump will always achieve the highest possible saturation level at a given temperature.
Gas solubility air example A common application for such pump technology is the dissolution of air into water. The volume of air that can be dissolved in water increases with the system pressure and decreases as the temperature lowers. While using air as an example, regenerative turbine pump gas dissolution can be calculated. The solubility of air in water can be expressed as a solubility ratio. Sa = ma / mw Where: Sa = solubility ratio ma = mass of air (lbm, kg) mw = mass of water (lbm, kg)
Solubility: Henry’s Law Meanwhile, Henry’s Law states that “the amount of air dissolved in a fluid is proportional with the pressure of the system.” Therefore, while fully utilizing Henry’s Law, the following symbols will be used: c = pg / kH Where: c = solubility of dissolved gas kH = proportionality constant depending on the nature of the gas and the fluid pg = partial pressure of the gas
Please note that the solubility of oxygen in water is higher than the solubility of nitrogen. Air that is dissolved in water contains approximately 35.6 percent oxygen; in comparison, ambient air only contains 21 percent oxygen.
Solubility calculation According to Henry’s Law, at a system temperature of 77°F the volume of air dissolved in water can be calculated as: Oxygen as O2 : 756.7 atm/(mol/liter) Nitrogen as N2 : 1600 atm/(mol/liter)
Molar Weights: O2 is 31.9988 g/mol N2 is 28.0134 g/mol
Partial Fraction in Air: O2 is about 0.21 N2 is about 0.79
The O2, which is dissolved in the water at atmospheric pressure, can be calculated as: co = (1 atm) 0.21 / (756.7 atm/(mol/liter)) (31.9988 g/mol)= 0.0089 g/liter, ~ 0.0089 g/kg
The N2, which is also dissolved in the water at atmospheric pressure, can be calculated as: cn = (1 atm) 0.79 / (1600 atm/(mol/liter)) (28.0134 g/mol) = 0.0138 g/liter, ~ 0.0138 g/kg
Since air is the sum of nitrogen and oxygen, the following results can be obtained: ca = (0.0089 g/liter) + (0.0138 g/liter) = 0.0227 g/liter ~ 0.023 g/kg
By applying such results to the regenerative turbine pump, a performance curve can be graphed. Note that the gas dissolution for air peaks at 10 percent by volume given normal system operating conditions with temperatures that do not exceed 100°F. The regenerative turbine pump discharge pressure meets or exceeds discharge requirements for most dissolved air flotation (DAF) when just 80 to 85 psi was applied in membrane and oil recovery applications. Please refer to Graph 1 for further information.
Why change? Of course, wastewater managers and technicians may use several older technological options as well in order to dissolve gasses into a liquid. In comparison to other options, the pump offers a competitive alternative for the following reasons: • Generates 20 to 30 micron sized bubbles. • Consumes less energy. • Dissolves gas at modest pressures. • Offers users a low wear pump fluid interface. • Utilizes a simple design that is easy to implement. • Provides high efficiency without causing cavitation. • Presents safety and control features that assure reliability. Design and applications Typically, a regenerative turbine pump is sized in saturation applications to just 20 percent of the total system flow. Therefore, the pumps are well suited for DAF membrane and oil recovery systems. Wastewater technicians will recognize that these pumps are useful in the food and beverage, laundry, pulp and paper, brewery and petroleum industries. Through further observation, they will also realize there are many other special process applications available as well.
Pump featuresRegenerative turbine pumps also have a robust construction. According to the list below, managers and technicians may consider the following reference points as they determine which quality pump design they will actually choose: • Materials: stainless steel, iron, brass • Close and flex-coupled models • May be mounted in many locations • Capacities of five to more than 120 GPM • Pump heads in excess of 200 feet • Economical seals Hydraulic design Regenerative turbine pumps can also be offered in single- or dual-impeller mechanical units. The internal hydraulic cavity is engineered to achieve maximum capacity and pressure while minimizing horsepower requirements. Such a design optimizes the fluid pumping dynamics within the interior passageway to improve the efficiency and overall pressure that users hope to achieve. Consequently, near complete dissolution of entrained gasses can be acquired at the highest volume possible during the pump cycle. This process is completed during a single pass, which leads to minimized horsepower requirements. Impeller tuningEach regenerative turbine impeller has a profile that is uniquely performance tuned. Tuning is based on engineered and field testing by optimizing the width and length of the impeller vanes. To efficiently dissolve gas into the fluid, horsepower must be reduced; such reduction usually improves off-peak horsepower requirements as well.
Blade efficiencyImpellers are built with blade profiles and counts, which have been engineered for their particular fluid passageway cross-sections. Impeller blade counts increase efficiency without leading to complex blade contours. Thus, the regenerative turbine pump yields high-performance characteristics that typically exceed those of more expensive units.
Adding it upWhile examining the air solubility calculations and also applying the regenerative turbine pump design, it appears that the results are within the expected efficiency range. Each of these results can be verified by using an air rotometer indicator, which should match the calculated volume. Accordingly, the net result equals a dissolved air release with 20 to 30 micron bubbles. Picture 4 vividly illustrates those bubbles within a DAF vessel; such bubbles are often referred to as “whitewater.”
Setting up gas dissolution systemsWastewater technicians should select pumps and piping materials according to the fluid type and temperature they expect to encounter. Operators must have full control of the system, as well as all built-in automatic safety features. The system should be also piped so that saturation time is maximized. The regenerative turbine pump ought to also match the overall system flow and hydraulic capacity. Of equal importance, technicians should also consider the following system limitations:
Discharge Pressure, 125 psi Seal Pressure, 200 psi Suction Vacuum, 26 inches Hg Speed (Flex), 1,750 rpm Speed (Close), 3,450 rpm Temperature, -20°F to 150°FSystem componentsA well-designed gas dissolution system will also have a number of components beyond just the pump itself. These items, which are usually either schedule 80 PVC or stainless steel, include the following: • Regenerative turbine pump • Inlet fluid control valve • Fluid vacuum gauge • Gas flow meter with adjustment knob • Gas tubing • Injection check valve • Discharge pressure gauge • Saturation and coalescing purge tank (optional) • Safety relief • Swing check valve • Discharge control valve • All necessary connecting piping • Mounting frame or plate Example setupThe following pictures illustrate a typical DAF system upgrade. In Picture 1, a regenerative turbine pump is fed clarified effluent water through a control valve with air injected via an acrylic rotometer. A slight vacuum is applied when atmospheric air is utilized. Wastewater technicians may find more controllable results by using compressed air pressures that range from 10 to 20 psi. Such pressures assure a more even flow and discourage fouling of the airline and rotometer. In Picture 2, a 125-psi safety and pump discharge pressure gauge are shown.
In Picture 3, the whitewater is introduced to the incoming system flow.
Regenerative turbine resultsAs a result of these efforts, a fully operable gas dissolution system can be developed. Over time, treatment operators will discover that they not only have a low maintenance unit, but reliable efficiency as well. Picture 4 shows the whitewater that is produced by 20 to 30 super saturated micron bubbles, as well as the formation of a dry sludge layer on the surface of the water. The final results are depicted in Picture 5 with the spillage of clarified water over the DAF effluent weir. PE
|